APG-L Archives

Archiver > APG > 1999-12 > 0944608337


From: "Dr. Gary Alan Dickey USA" <>
Subject: Re: [APG] CD Reviews, etc.
Date: Tue, 7 Dec 1999 18:12:17 -0500


-------------------- Begin Original Message --------------------

Message text written by INTERNET:

"An open board would give feedback to APG on problems, potential or
perceived
problems with almost any genealogical product. The downside is the
malcontents will rave and rant, but it's a free country. Just having a
board
where people can contribute their comments does not mean APG approves of
them -- only that it listens."


-------------------- End Original Message --------------------

Myra,

There is another downside. This has become a problem at some of the news
groups and Forums. This is the issue of libel that is open to lawsuits.
Printing reviews is one thing; printing something detrimental to a person
or organization (that affects their reputation or economic wellbeing)
without proper documentation may open a group or person to the possibility
of being sued to recoup costs of merchandise not sold or civil damages to
regain one's reputation. This means, therefore, that serious consideration
would have to be given to insurance for indemnification for such issues.
This brings up issues of criteria of what is or is not "up to standards."
It can be a "slippery slope" that needs to be carefully looked at. Large
companies are suing for comments made in different Forums­it is not just a
rumor. Of course, it does not matter if the case goes to court or gets
settled, but it will cost a lot to make it "go away."

Gary

This thread: