CARMACK-L Archives

Archiver > CARMACK > 1998-12 > 0913119974


From: "Dale Carmack" <>
Subject: Re: Evan Carmack Problem
Date: Tue, 8 Dec 1998 07:26:14 -0500


Hi Gary, I'm still confused. I have 4 Evans in my data, as follows:

Descendants of Jacob Carmack

1 Jacob Carmack Born: 1769 in Frederick Co., MD Died: 1814 in Frederick
Co., MD
.. +Catherine Carmack
2 Mary "Polly" Carmack
.... +Jacob Snyder
2 Sally "Sarah" Carmack
.... +Sharp
2 Christian S. Carmack
.... +Mary Springer
2 Evan Carmack
2 Jacob Carmack, Jr. Died: 1846 in ,, OH
.... +Ann Rebecca Winnell
2 Samuel Carmack Born: August 29, 1792 Died: August 01, 1879 in ,
Frederick Co., MD
.... +Caroline "Smitty" Smith Born: March 22, 1800 Died: March 28, 1881 in
, Frederick Co., MD

Descendants of William Carmack

1 William Carmack Born: 1716 in ,Kent/Cecil Co, MD Died: May 1776 in
,Frederick Co, MD
.. +Jane McDaniel
2 Sarah Carmack Born: July 02, 1733 in ,Kent/Cecil Co, MD Died: Abt 1791
in , Frederick Co, MD
.... +John Brightwell Born: 1720 Died: 1791
2 Cornelius Carmack Born: June 18, 1736 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died: July
18, 1824 in Livingston, Overton Co, TN
.... +Margery Jane Evans Born: 1736
2 William Carmack, Jr Born: November 10, 1738 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died:
May 16, 1825 in ,Frederick Co, MD
.... +Rachael C Richards
2 Evan Carmack Born: February 25, 1739/40 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died: Bef.
1814 in Wheeling,, WV
.... +Mary Wolfe Born: 1748 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died: January 03, 1805 in
Wheeling,, WV
2 John Cornelius Carmack Born: May 12, 1742 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died:
December 1796 in Woodsboro, Frederick Co, MD
.... +Sarah C Wolfe Born: 1747 Died: August 10, 1822 in Woodsboro,
Frederick Co, MD
2 Nathan Carmack Born: November 17, 1748 in ,Frederick Co, MD
2 Levi Carmack Born: November 03, 1750 in Woodsboro, Frederick Co, MD
Died: December 03, 1785 in Woodsboro, Frederick Co, MD
.... +Susannah Justice Born: March 03, 1747/48 Died: July 26, 1834 in
Shandon, Butler Co, OH
2 Aquilla Carmack Born: January 13, 1754 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died:
February 25, 1811 in ,Davidson Co, TN
.... +Benny Cartwright Died: September 05, 1785
*2nd Wife of Aquilla Carmack:
.... +Eunice Williams Born: February 11, 1756 in ,,NC Died: April 1822 in
,Davidson Co, TN

Descendants of William Carmack

1 William Carmack Born: January 05, 1761 in ,Frederick Co, MD Died:
September 24, 1851 in ,Lee Co, VA
.. +Mary Catherine Hartsock
2 Enoch Carmack Born: July 24, 1785 in ,Lee Co, VA
2 Barbara Carmack Born: January 21, 1787 in ,Lee Co, VA
.... +Benjamin Smith
2 Kesiah Carmack Born: December 14, 1789 in ,Lee Co, VA
2 Levi Carmack Born: December 09, 1791 in ,Lee Co, VA Died: August 03,
1866
.... +Elizabeth "Sally" Peters Born: 1791 in England Died: September 20,
1881
2 Allen Carmack Born: December 03, 1793 in ,Lee Co, VA Died: Abt 1870 in
,Sullivan Co, MO
.... +Sarah Dougherty Born: 1789 Died: 1874
2 Evan Carmack Born: 1796 in ,Lee Co, VA Died: Aft. 1870 in ,Dent Co, MO
.... +Lydia Kaylor Born: 1802 in ,,VA Died: 1870
*2nd Wife of William Carmack:
.. +Mary Yeary

Descendants of Levi Carmack

1 Levi Carmack Born: December 09, 1791 in ,Lee Co, VA Died: August 03,
1866
.. +Elizabeth "Sally" Peters Born: 1791 in England Died: September 20, 1881
2 Kesiah Carmack Born: October 20, 1812
.... +Dan Ayers
2 Kate Carmack Born: May 05, 1814
.... +Isaac Godsey
2 Isaac Carmack Born: March 29, 1816 Died: 1862
.... +Comfort Hale
2 Mary Ann Carmack Born: March 08, 1820 Died: September 05, 1841
.... +David Redmond
2 William Carmack Born: March 14, 1822
.... +Nancy Cox
2 Levi Carmack, Jr. Born: March 04, 1824
.... +Caroline
2 Abraham Carmack Born: October 22, 1826 Died: May 16, 1910
.... +Alcy Ann Dean
2 John Carmack Born: 1827
2 Jacob Carmack Born: February 25, 1828
2 Elizabeth Carmack Born: May 06, 1830
.... +James Longworth
2 Evan Carmack Born: August 01, 1832
.... +Elizabeth Lundy
2 Martin Carmack Born: May 29, 1834 Died: August 01, 1908 in ,Clayborne
Co, TN
.... +Sarah Barnes
2 Enoch Carmack Born: July 03, 1836 Died: September 24, 1932
.... +Sarah Campbell Born: June 11, 1841 Died: December 27, 1931

I have Evan/Lydia as the son of William and Mary Hartstock.

Regarding Willam and Elizabeth, I have the following:
Descendants of William Carmack

1 William Carmack Born: Bet. 1760 - 1770 in , Washingon Co. VA Died:
September 24, 1849
.. +Elizabeth Walker Died: August 12, 1826
2 Sarah "Sally" Carmack Born: Bet. 1790 - 1800 in , Washingon Co. VA
.... +Alexander Susong
2 Cornelius "Neil" Carmack Born: August 22, 1800 in , Washingon Co. VA
Died: June 19, 1877
.... +Martha "Patsy" Susong Born: December 17, 1805 Died: July 02, 1887
2 William Carmack Born: September 04, 1803 in , Washingon Co. VA Died:
January 22, 1877 in , Washingon Co. VA
.... +Hannah Elizabeth Burkhart Born: Abt 1811
2 Mary Elizabeth Carmack Born: March 29, 1806 in , Washingon Co. VA Died:
January 01, 1893
.... +Isaac Gray
2 James Walter Carmack Born: April 30, 1808 in , Washingon Co. VA Died:
April 06, 1881
.... +Martha Tipton Weeks
2 Isaac Carmack Born: 1813 in , Washingon Co. VA Died: April 24, 1876
.... +Jane Campbell
2 Alfred Carmack Born: June 14, 1814 in , Washingon Co. VA Died: November
26, 1873
.... +Menerva Crockett
2 John W. Carmack Born: September 01, 1816 in , Washingon Co. VA Died:
July 19, 1868 in Stanton, , VA
.... +Matilda Lyons
2 Robert Carmack Born: Abt 1820 in , Washingon Co. VA
.... +Susannah
2 William Rhea Carmack Born: Abt 1820 in , Washingon Co. VA

All of the above children of William and Elizabeth came from Carmack Cousins
Newsletter, Volume 1, No. 2, December 1, 1984, page 3. There was no mention
of Evan in this family. Could you have him placed in the wrong William?

Thanks,
dale

-----Original Message-----
From: Gary Long <>
To: <>
Date: Monday, December 07, 1998 10:56 PM
Subject: Evan Carmack Problem

>There are at least three Evan Carmacks, maybe more. This one, Evan of
>Washington County who married Lydia Kaylor, is in my direct line. So, I
>have checked it out fairly well. I have verified the marriage:
>
> In Washington Co., VA Marriages; 1776-1855; abs. by Hiatt & Scott,
> note that his name is spelled diff:
>
> Carmack, Ewan & Lydia Kaylor, 16 May 1818 minister Jeriel Dodge
>
>I have only one descendant (of many I think), who is of course also in my
>line. Elizabeth Carmack (6/11/1882 - 6/30/1887) married John Young in Va.
>
>Evan and Lydia moved to Missouri shortly after the marriage. Lydia's
>parents were Daniel Kaylor and Elizabeth Weeks. I have Evan as b. 1796,
>descended from William Carmack and Eliz. Walker.
>
>-- Gary Long
>
>Washington Co. later divided, Lee Co. created.
>At 02:18 AM 12/5/98 -0800, you wrote:
>>Date: Fri, 4 Dec 1998 22:56:00 -0500
>>From: "Dale Carmack" <>
>>To:
>>Message-ID: <006f01be2003$2bd62dc0$>
>>Subject: RE: Evan 1740
>>Content-Type: text/plain;
>> charset="iso-8859-1"
>>Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
>>
>>I was talking about the other Evan, let me try again. On page 4 of Vol 2,
>>No. 2 listed are the children of Jacob (1769-1814) and Catherine. A.4.10
>>lists Evan, married to Lydia Kaylor. However, my data had this Evan b
1796
>>(& also married to Lydia Kaylor) as the son of William b 1761 and Mary
>>Hartsock.
>>
>>I am not referring to the 1740 Evan, son of William and Jane.
>>
>>Can anyone clear up which parent Evan who is married to Lydia Kaylor is
>>attached to?
>>
>>thanks,
>>dale
>>
>
>
>==== CARMACK Mailing List ====
>My family tree is full of notholes... it's NOT him, it's NOT her!

This thread: