GEN-DE-L Archives

Archiver > GEN-DE > 2001-11 > 1004829794


From: "GeeTee" <>
Subject: Re: Aribert Stampa 1706
Date: Sun, 4 Nov 2001 10:23:14 +1100
References: <o6GE7.6931$zl4.207038@news2.tin.it>, <MNHE7.3566$w61.163767@ozemail.com.au>, <9s0n9c$vrkck$1@ID-101531.news.dfncis.de>


I can not see what is your problem.

Your statement (bellow) makes it very clear that anyone who has an Italian
background is welcome to seek information. Read your own message.
I share 100 your comments. Any one from any country can (and has the right)
to seek information and participate as long as what he seeks information
about his Italian roots (Genealogical information).

>Very true.... and in public, as the politeness require they speak Italian.
As I
>speak (or better make my best effort to do so) English when I'm in England
>or French when in France etc.........
>I've got friends living in centre Africa, they have sons born there,
>uau!!! this gives italians who speak swaili!!!! What about a post in
swaili? Or in
>yddish, there are italians in Israel too!? And would'nt be nice in chinese,
>mandarine of corse, or Japanese or one of the thousands russian dialects?
>Are You getting the picture? This would be a Babel and nobody would be
>able to help anybody.

You try to trivialise an very serious issue, that does not say much about
your
intelligence and fairness. I have my doubts that any one from China will
post a message,
and Swahili is the language of Nomads in Tanzania/Kenia/Uganda. I have my
doubts if
any Italian speak Swahili and do not speak Italian/English. Get the
picture??
Of course you may try to suggest that only Italians who speak English and
Italian are Italians.
The are hundreds of thousands of Italians living in Brazil (Portuguese) and
Argentina (Spanish)
and millions working and living in Germany and Austria (German). No to
mentioned the Swiss
Italians, Greeks of Italian descent (close to a million), etc.
I am please to see that you accept they have some rights too.

> this is not a philosophical NG, if You'd like to make a contest in
rhetoric,
> please try on alt.philosophy.blablabla.......

I agree, it's not a Philosophical issue, it's a genealogical issue.
So lets stick to Genealogical issues.

Dr. George Tsambourakis
343 Major's Line Road
Tooborac, Victoria 3522, Australia

"Mauro" <> wrote in message
news:9s0n9c$vrkck$1@ID-101531.news.dfncis.de...
>
> > However, if the newsgroup was created, to create a forum to discuss
> Italian
> > genealogy and to assist those who have or believe that they have some
> > Italian blood in their genealogy, than you are not correct.
>
>
>
>
> > Italian Genealogy does not in any way imply that Italian Language is the
> > only language. Italian genealogy does not exclude "German", "French", or
> > "Greek". as these three languages are spoken languages in Italy.
>
> *******************************************
> Please set brain in 'mode ON' before reathing further!!!
> *******************************************
>
> Very true.... and in public, as the politeness require they speak
> Italian. As I
> speak (or better make my best effort to do so) english when I'm in England
> or
> French when in France etc.........
> I've got friends living in center Africa, they have sons born there,
> uau!!! this
> gives italians who speak swaili!!!! What about a post in swaili? Or in
> yddish,
> there are italians in Israel too!? And would'nt be nice in chinese,
> mandarine of
> corse, or Japanese or one of the thousands russian dialects?
> Are You getting the picture? This would be a Babel and nobody would be
> able to help anybody.
>
> >
> > I have to read the original proposal.
>
> Absolutely!! And menwhile read my post and try to understand before
> flaming!!! I did non say that the question whas'nt in the right place,
I've
> just wrote an invitation to write the question in english or italian,
since
> the question would have had a better hope to get an answer!!!
>
> By the way!!! .... should I remember You that in the signatures the
> titles are considered not elegant (give a look to the 'Galateo')? Just
sign
> with your name followed by the surname if You aren't concerned with
> privacy....
>
>


This thread: