RootsWeb: GENEALOGY-DNA-L Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP

GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2005-11 > 1133223374

From: Dr Jim Hull <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP
Date: Mon, 28 Nov 2005 16:16:14 -0800 (PST)
In-Reply-To: <REME20051128173222@alum.mit.edu>

"The facts that most of us are looking for are genealogical, rather than anthropological. SNP testing, as presently constituted, is *much* less valuable than any kind of STR upgrade on the market." John Chandler <> wrote: John Chandler's reply is undoubtedly the most profound and original thought that has been expressed at this website in a coons-age. Generally, this website gives me a good laugh followed by gas! But, today was different! Data here, 1004 - Over and out! Jon --------------------------------- Yahoo! Music Unlimited - Access over 1 million songs. Try it free.

This thread:

Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by Bonnie Schrack <>

Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>

Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by Doug McDonald <>

RE: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by "Lowe DNA" <>

Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by David Faux <>
- RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by David Faux <>
    - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
- Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
- Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by Alice Fairhurst <>
  - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
- Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>

RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
- RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
    - RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
- Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by (John Chandler)

RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
- Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by (John Chandler)
  - RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "John McEwan" <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by Dr Jim Hull <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
- RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by
- Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by "Phil Goff" <>

RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by John Lerch <>

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by
- Redrawing the YCC Chart by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by (John Chandler)
    - RE: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart + Charles' log by
    - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart + Charles' log by charles <>
  - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by
  - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by "robert mclaren" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by (John Chandler)

New J haplogroup nomenclature by Bonnie Schrack <>