RootsWeb: GENEALOGY-DNA-L Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart

GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2005-11 > 1133297189

From: (John Chandler)
Subject: Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart
Date: Tue, 29 Nov 2005 15:46:29 -0500 (EST)
References: <IGEOKAGLHNEKPCKPADIGMEJDKOAA.bbailey.lowedna@baileyconnection.com>
In-Reply-To: <IGEOKAGLHNEKPCKPADIGMEJDKOAA.bbailey.lowedna@baileyconnection.com>

Bill wrote: > Thanks for the Depuy study information. Has anyone done a study where 3 or > more generations of the same family men have been tested to determine if the > divergent marker(s) mutation remain "fixed" once they mutated away from the > father ? It's unlikely such a study would ever be done. It would have to be a very BIG study to be of any use (at least 100,000 certified and willing grandfather-father-son triples), and a positive result is theoretically impossible. Who is going to fund a project like that? John Chandler

This thread:

Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by

Redrawing the YCC Chart by "Lowe DNA" <>

Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by (John Chandler)

RE: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by "Lowe DNA" <>

Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart + Charles' log by
- Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart + Charles' log by charles <>

Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by

Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by "robert mclaren" <>
- Re: [DNA] Redrawing the YCC Chart by (John Chandler)

Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by Bonnie Schrack <>
- Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
  - Re: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by Doug McDonald <>
  - RE: [DNA] New J haplogroup nomenclature by "Lowe DNA" <>
  - Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by David Faux <>
    - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
      - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by David Faux <>
        RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by Alice Fairhurst <>
      - RE: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by "Lowe DNA" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Designing a New Phylogenetic Tree Based on New Findings by
  - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
    - RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
      - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
        Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
      - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
        Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
      - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by (John Chandler)
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
        Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by (John Chandler)
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "John McEwan" <>
        Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by Dr Jim Hull <>
        Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, andback mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by charles <>
        RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by "Lowe DNA" <>
    - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by
      - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by "Phil Goff" <>
    - RE: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutation issues -- to YSNP or not to YSNP by John Lerch <>
    - Re: [DNA] YSNP testing, hobby scientist forces, convergence, and back mutatio... by