RootsWeb: GENEALOGY-DNA-L Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches

GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2006-02 > 1139669251

From: Doug McDonald <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches
Date: Sat, 11 Feb 2006 08:47:31 -0600
References: <000e01c62ec5$f6e14030$77de4a0c@cicadaneu0kf7n>
In-Reply-To: <000e01c62ec5$f6e14030$77de4a0c@cicadaneu0kf7n>

Sue Waite-Langley wrote: > I'm curious as to why so many administrators are so fast to jump on the > parallel mutation bandwagon. One reason is finding rock solid paper trails where you DO find separate mutations that define the separate branches, and then finding parallel mutations is different sub-branches. The other is the math ... they really ARE to be expected, especially for the fastest markers. The marker speed does not matter for what the TMRCA is, but it DOES matter in regard to where (which markers) you expect to find the mutations. Doug McDonald

This thread:

Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Michael Corson <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Robert Stafford <>
- RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>
  - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>
    - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>
- Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Robert Stafford <>
- Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Robert Stafford <>
- Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Doug McDonald <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>
    - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>
    - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>
      - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>
        RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>
        RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Hal Whitmore <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>
      - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Doug McDonald <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Doug McDonald <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Doug McDonald <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>

RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Clyde Rice <>
- RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Nancy Custer" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>
    - Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "William Hurst" <>
      - Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by <>
        Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "William Hurst" <>
        Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations, was = Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Peter A. Kincaid" <>
- RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by OrinWells <>
  - Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by (John Chandler)
    - Re: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by Clyde Rice <>
  - RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by Clyde Rice <>
    - RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by OrinWells <>
      - RE: [DNA] Parallel Mutations by "Roberta J. Estes" <>
  - Re: Parallel mutations (Was: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors), etc by Gary Merrill <>
    - Re: Parallel mutations by charles <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
- RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>
- Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
    - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>
      - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>
        RE:John Chandler's Mutation analysis - was [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>
        RE: John Chandler's Mutation Rate analysis - was [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Terry Barton" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>
    - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by charles <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by John Lerch <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by John Lerch <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "William A. Sirmon" <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by John Lerch <>
- RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
- RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Diana Gale Matthiesen" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Doug McDonald <>
    - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Diana Gale Matthiesen" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
    - RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Diana Gale Matthiesen" <>
      - Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by (John Chandler)
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Sue Waite-Langley" <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        DNA Simulation and Modeling WAS Earliest common ancestors for 37/37and 43/43 matches by Rebekah A Canada <>
        Re: [DNA] DNA Simulation and Modeling WAS Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Rebekah A Canada <>
        Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by John Lerch <>
- RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by OrinWells <>

RE: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by John Lerch <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Eric Olson" <>
- Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by Rebekah A Canada <>

Re: [DNA] Earliest common ancestors for 37/37 and 43/43 matches by "Eric Olson" <>