GENEALOGY-DNA-L ArchivesArchiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2006-04 > 1145547670
From: "Mark MacDonald" <>
Subject: RE: [DNA] DNA Project Conscription
Date: Thu, 20 Apr 2006 10:55:53 -0500
From a legal and ethical perspective I don't think there is a prohibition.
When someone posts on y search there is intentional data disclosure to the
public, especially a disclosure and use consistent with a web site. Ysearch
purports to limit use to non commercial or educational purpose. Without
deciding the difficult legal question whether that language works to limit
use, why should a non commercial use not be available? Is the data even
copyrightable under US law? Does the valuable data mining by Nordtvedt or
McEwan create a legal or ethical breach? I don't think so.
Jim's response is expressly just an opinion but Mike shouldn't regard it as
definitive. Mike just asked a difficult question about which reasonable
minds can disagree whether it would be appropriate.
From: jim berry [mailto:]
Sent: Thursday, April 20, 2006 10:20 AM
Subject: [DNA] DNA Project Conscription
Since you asked, in my opinion you have NO right to add anyone to
your project nor upload their 'numbers' to Ysearch without their
On Apr 20, 2006, at 9:08 AM, "Michael L. Hébert"
> I am a newbie to genetic genealogy and am still on the learning curve.
> recently started a couple of DNA surname projects. For my Woodruff
> I've gone into the SMGF database and teased out the numbers for the
> Woodruffs in there and was going to add them to my project site as a
> way of
> getting things kick started. Using the Athey predictor site, three of
> SMGF Woodruffs, as well as my Woodruff uncle, seem to be R1b.
> However, one
> of the SMGF Woodruffs is predicted as I1a.
> My question is, can and should I add these SMGF numbers to Ysearch to
> them available to other researchers? SMGF's terms
> (http://smgf.org/page.jspx?name=legal) don't seem to forbid it since
> would be for an "educational and non-commercial" purpose. Any
> thoughts on
> this would be appreciated.
> Anyway, below are the I1a numbers (using FTDNA lab standard) for the
> Woodruff. Does this particular haplotype indicate Norse origin? If
> so, I
> might mention this in my project announcements as a way of perhaps
> more Woodruffs to get tested.
Searching BERRY HESSE WALL GEORGE KING STACY VOSSICK FORSTER SCOTT
KIRKLAND et al
Graveyards & Gravestones
Berry Bibles Project
Berry Family DNA Project
New! Family Tree Maker 2005. Build your tree and search for your ancestors
at the same time. Share your tree with family and friends. Learn more:
|RE: [DNA] DNA Project Conscription by "Mark MacDonald" <>|