GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

From: James Heald <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ?
Date: Mon, 16 Apr 2007 00:38:58 +0100
References: <461F9F20.9010003@comcast.net> <46223AAE.1020802@ucl.ac.uk><462293CF.5090608@sbcglobal.net>
In-Reply-To: <462293CF.5090608@sbcglobal.net>

Alfred A. Aburto Jr. wrote:

>
> There were other refinements of the Cohanim Y-DNA structure that were
> published 18 months later by Thomas et al (1998), also published in
> Nature. However, I haven't figured out Y-DNA structure yet in terms of
> the current Y-DNA Tree. If any has please respond too.
> Al
>

The Wikipedia article now organises the data, and has links to the
original papers:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-chromosomal_Aaron

The haplogroup numbers from Thomas et al (1998) count the number
"xDE,PR" -- ie not in Hgs D, E, P, Q, R

Behar et al (2003) have a more detailed breakdown of Cohanim numbers by
haplotype, from a slightly enlarged sample.


The article doesn't include Bonnie's wonderful breakthrough yet, which -
with luck - means we may be getting close to finally getting the story
sorted out!

This thread:

• [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by Bonnie Schrack <>
  • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
  • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
    • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
    • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
  • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
    • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by ellen Levy <>
      • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
        • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
  • [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>

      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>

        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Rebekah <>
    • [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
      • [DNA] Cohen data from Behar (2003) by James Heald <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
              • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
                • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>
              • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by John Cartmell <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Steven Bird" <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
              • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Dienekes Pontikos" <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Sasson Margaliot" <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by John Cartmell <>
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        • [DNA] Article in Australian news daily by "Wickwire, Rick" <>
          • Re: [DNA] Article in Australian news daily by "Dora Smith" <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by James Heald <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by ellen Levy <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
      • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
        • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by (John Chandler)
          • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Alfred A. Aburto Jr." <>
            • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by "Max Heffler" <>
    • Re: [DNA] Malaspina et al (2001)'s Cohens -- an answer ? by Bonnie Schrack <>
  • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH,CMH does not equal Cohen -- only in J1 do they coincide by Bonnie Schrack <>
  • Re: [DNA] Cohen does not equal CMH, CMH does not equal Cohen by "Victor Villarreal" <>