GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2008-01 > 1199195988


From: "Sasson Margaliot" <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] SNPs appearing in multiple haplogroups
Date: Tue, 1 Jan 2008 15:59:48 +0200
References: <3b2a446a0712300534i578809fam801efc3ddccb6e32@mail.gmail.com><BAY103-DAV200903293959FB5F6CBFF3C8570@phx.gbl>
In-Reply-To: <BAY103-DAV200903293959FB5F6CBFF3C8570@phx.gbl>


Now Wikipedia is saying that there is a Haplogroup CF based on P143 and
parallel to DE.
What uis this P143 ?

The name CF is clearly wrong because according to the YCC rules FC means
"everything between C and F in alphabetical order": C,D,E and F. So CF
means the same thing as CR, because F includes groups from H to R.

The new Haplogroup should be called FC (instead of CF).

In terms of 67 markers. is C closer to F than it is to D and E, when modal
haplotypes are compared? In other words, does STR information mirror the
SNP-based tree?

Sasson


On Dec 30, 2007 10:41 PM, RICHARD KENYON <> wrote:

> ymap shows a number of SNPs that can appear in more than one
> haplogroup. These are indicated in ymap by fractional SNP numbers, such as
> M64.1 and M64.2. Here's a list from ymap (possibly incomplete):
> M64.1 D2
> M64.2 R1a1c [same location, same polymorphism]
> M108.1 B2a2
> M108.1 B2a3a (ISOGG) [ditto]
> M116.1 D2a
> M116.2 E3a2 (ISOGG) [ditto]
> M359.1 D2 (ISOGG only)
> M359.2 I1b1a (ISOGG), I2a1 (FTDNA 2008)
> MSY2.1 B2b4b
> MSY2.2 O1 [ditto]
> P9.1 CR
> P9.2 E1b1a7a1 (FTDNA 2008) [ditto]
> P27.1 P
> P27.2 O3a1 (FTDNA 2008) [ditto]
> P41.1 D2 (same as M359.1)
> P41.2 see M359.2 [ditto]
> SRY 1532.1 BR (ISOGG only)
> SRY 1532.2 R1a (ISOGG only) [ditto]
> SRY 10831.1 same as SRY 1532.1
> SRY 10831.2 same as SRY 1532.2
>
> But to answer the question you asked: I don't know!
>
> Richard R. Kenyon ("Dick")
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: Sasson Margaliot<mailto:>
> To: <mailto:>
> Sent: Sunday, December 30, 2007 5:34 AM
> Subject: [DNA] The TDNA Haplogroup FC ?
>
>
> Is it true that a SNP was discovered which is common to Haplogroups C and
> F
> ?
>
>
> Sasson
>
>
>

This thread: