GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2009-06 > 1244372708


From: Vincent Vizachero <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] revised TMRCA calcuations for the R-L21 results
Date: Sun, 7 Jun 2009 07:05:08 -0400
References: <5cf61dfb0905271916i4cfa488ev898809742fec5011@mail.gmail.com><A540FBA8E36A45D98C3542B9925C966C@DadPC><D8ABB0BCF28148F4B30DB7924010A469@RichardNW><8436110BE83A4381A3D911976CEE388B@DadPC><00e701c9e09c$e56c74a0$6400a8c0@Ken1><F2FF9463B36B4806B096A777CFBF9AC7@DadPC><2433EAC81B0D45DD84DF19817C8C7129@RichardNW><4951E546E48140E593AFDC50CFBDD27D@DadPC><8187F898BD744F5199D9489FA1FB6C36@RichardNW><ECDB539D49FE42CEA3A60E218CC14BD4@DadPC><05713DAEDC51446B94799B2A4E3B2ED2@RichardNW><033CB361F6A544C78E0A3F7C8F2007E2@DadPC><17B70CA401E2423D86E4DE5127442FA5@RichardNW><C9547F2C13F941C1B1F2942D024844E0@DadPC><1DB1BA87-3C94-45C9-8EB6-5323B7908E27@vizachero.com><8C698AC5822F486FB8099F716705FDC0@DadPC>
In-Reply-To: <8C698AC5822F486FB8099F716705FDC0@DadPC>


No blinders, just research.

Anyway, you didn't accurately capture what I wrote. R-P25 did not go
"into Europe to spawn R-M269". R-M269 first emerged in Asia ( in the
Near East, most likely) and entered Europe afterwards.

VV


On Jun 6, 2009, at 9:28 PM, Peter A. Kincaid wrote:

> You have blinders on to say that some R-P25 went into Europe
> to spawn R-M269 and R-M73 but the R-P25* had to come
> from the R-P25 that remained in the east.


This thread: