RootsWeb: GENEALOGY-DNA-L Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269?

GENEALOGY-DNA-L Archives

Archiver > GENEALOGY-DNA > 2010-05 > 1274933840

From: "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
Subject: Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269?
Date: Wed, 26 May 2010 22:17:20 -0600
References: <868513.40413.qm@web81103.mail.mud.yahoo.com><440908FA-40B1-4EAB-96C6-944BCDB9F02E@vizachero.com><AANLkTikARWP7xvxuGdeyHkWJYNycuxh2VI7mzoh-EQnn@mail.gmail.com>

----- Original Message ----- From: "David Faux" <> We need > ancient DNA evidence. If U152 is found in a 10,000 year old sample then > it > is at least that old and we will have to keep searching for more samples > to > find out when only the ancestral version P312 occurs. How many failures to find 10,000 year old U152 would you need to abandon your hypothesis? Otherwise such a search could be a bottomless pit into which unbounded resources and time could be devoured.

This thread:

[DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithic orPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Vincent Vizachero <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Gary Felix <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Vincent Vizachero <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Gary Felix <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Allene Goforth" <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>

[DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithic orPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by JacquesBeaugrand <>
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about NeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?. by "Alister John Marsh" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about NeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?. by
    - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about NeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?. by "Alister John Marsh" <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Vincent Vizachero <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithic or Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Tom Gull <>
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
  - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithic or Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Tom Gull <>
    - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by vernade didier <>
      - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by (John Chandler)
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Alister John Marsh" <>
  - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debateabout Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by (John Chandler)
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about NeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about NeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
  - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
      - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to thedebateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to thedebateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Alister John Marsh" <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
  - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
    - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
      - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Sasson Margaliot <>
        Re: [DNA] Zhiv (was Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate . . ..) by Vincent Vizachero <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithic or Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithic or Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Vincent Vizachero <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithic or Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Lawrence Mayka" <>
      - Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by David Faux <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?- by "Alister John Marsh" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate aboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?- by David Faux <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?- by "Ken Nordtvedt" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to thedebateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?- by "Alister John Marsh" <>
        Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debateaboutNeolithicorPaleolithic dispersal of R-M269?- by David Faux <>
      - [DNA] Ancestry test versus MTDNA test by Nelda Percival <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by Dienekes Pontikos <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about Neolithicor Paleolithic dispersal of R-M269? by SVass <>

Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about by "Anatole Klyosov" <>
- Re: [DNA] Does Sardinia hold the key to the debate about by David Faux <>