TMG-L Archives

Archiver > TMG > 2010-08 > 1282946359


From: "Darrell A. Martin" <>
Subject: Re: [TMG] Wish List: Leave My Punctuation Alone Code!
Date: Fri, 27 Aug 2010 16:59:19 -0500
References: <2010826174726.317903@Terry> <4C76F205.1060104@sprynet.com> <201008270110.o7R19xHl031350@mail.rootsweb.com> <4C7739D9.8070000@sprynet.com> <201008270447.o7R4lXMS001681@mail.rootsweb.com> <4C7744F3.6020009@sprynet.com> <201008271442.o7REgb7u028070@mail.rootsweb.com> <4C77D8F7.5050200@gmail.com> <00d901cb4602$efb0a040$cf11e0c0$@net> <4C77E73A.8090901@gmail.com> <4C77EC36.7030104@sprynet.com> <201008271730.o7RHUPve025389@mail.rootsweb.com> <4C780100.6030500@sprynet.com> <4C7806A3.40706@gmail.com> <00e801cb461e$b497edd0$1dc7c970$@net><4C78189F.90902@gmail.com>
In-Reply-To: <4C78189F.90902@gmail.com>


Rick Van Dusen wrote:
> Okay, I understand fully/agree fully with all you've said here. However,
> we then get talking about using the Memo field for "supplemental data
> fields", and we get into all kinds of detail issues. It's with these
> details that I'm asking, "If you're willing to alter the format of the
> Memo, why not the local sentence?"

Rick:

How do you alter the *format* of
the Memo?

> If we stick with using the Memo field as a "free-form" field (where we
> are able to enter a big block of text of any form), that's a different
> matter altogether, and the whole point is to make a one-time entry that
> only applies in this one instance and therefore is not worth changing
> our database structure to accommodate. And there, my confusion doesn't
> apply.

But that is all that a Memo (or more
correctly a Memo segment), is: a
free-form text field. The whole point
of ANY memo is exactly what you said,
always, as long as by "instance" you
mean "Tag". (It is possible to output
a Memo segment many times for one
Tag, in different Role sentences.)

> (In either type of use, the punctuation should stay as we put it within
> our Memo entry.)

Except for the standard case in
which a Memo ends a sentence, I
agree. If a Memo does end a
sentence, I might still agree;
but I might not. It depends. In
those cases I want the computer
to do the work, *provided* I have
a way to easily assert control.

Darrell



This thread: