Y-DNA-HAPLOGROUP-I-L Archives

Archiver > Y-DNA-HAPLOGROUP-I > 2011-01 > 1294855192


From: Roy Silfven <>
Subject: [yDNAhgI] I1 AS9b Geographic Origins Results
Date: Wed, 12 Jan 2011 09:59:52 -0800


Below is the breakdown of the I1 AS9b group’s geographic origins using
Terry’s “STR Cluster Decision Tree, and compared to user submitted
ancestral locations:

Of the 4 Kits claiming Norway as the location:

1 result of ABB (Norway is the hotspot on this map so this result is
correct)

3 results of AAA (Norway is included on this map. The hotspots seem to
be England and France, but also covers a broad area of northern Europe)

Of the 4 kits claiming UK/England:

1 result of AAA (England is the hotspot on this map, a
correct position)

1 result of AAB (Includes England but hotspots are Ireland, Scotland,
& France)

2 results of ABA (Includes England but dimmer than
Ireland, Scotland, France, & Germany

Of the 2 kits claiming Germany:

2 results of AAA (Germany is part of this map but less
hot than England and France)

Of the 2 kits claiming Finland:

2 results of AAA (Finland appears on this map but is the
weakest shading)

1 kit claiming Sweden: 1 result of AAA (Sweden included on this map at
lesser shading)

Of the 7 kits with unknown ancestral locations:

4 results of AAA

1 result of AAB

2 results of ABB

Of the 13 kits, 2 results equaled the ancestral location supplied by
the submitter. 9 results were "technically" correct but did not the
pin pointed location supplied by the submitter.

The 2 kits for Finland (one of them is mine) have a value of 14 at
DYS557 and as such do not fit into the framework of the model. For
this experiment I used 15 in place of the 14 – 15 being the value of
about 65% of AS9b at this marker. Still, the supporting genealogy for
the ancestors of these 2 individuals is Hailuoto and Haukipudas,
Finland going back well over 300 years. I would have expected them to
fall into either BA* or BBA.


Roy Silfven





This thread: